1. 1.1.4

The Illiad

But Achilles hath wrought to fury the proud heart within him, cruel man! neither recketh he of the love of his comrades wherewith we ever honoured him amid the ships above all others—pitiless one! Lo, a man accepteth recompense from the slayer of his brother, or for his dead son; and the slayer abideth in his own land for the paying of a great price, and the kinsman's heart and proud spirit are restrained by the taking of recompense.

If the notion of tort law is ancient, can we intuit it?

Roadmap

  • What are torts?
  • Intentional torts
    • E.g., assault and battery
  • Negligence
    • Unintentional carelessness which results in harm
  • Strict liability
    • Briefly, as we will cover during product liability

What is a tort?

A tort is a legally-actionable wrong. If you or your property has been injured by another, tort law is likely your remedy.

What’s the point? First, make you whole

  • Put you in the same position as if there had been no tort
  • Compensatory damages
    • Special damages = we can put a price tag on it
      • Medical expenses, lost wages
    • General damages = harder to put a price tag on
      • Pain and suffering
      • Loss of companionship
      • Disfigurement

What’s the point? At times, punish

  • Punitive damages
    • Punish the wrongdoer
    • Generally only available for intentional torts and gross negligence, with a higher degree of culpability
    • Due process limitations ….

Intentional Torts

Battery

Battery is …

  • unauthorized
  • intentional
    • actual intent, or
    • substantial certainty
  • harmful or offensive
  • physical contact
  • with another person or their immediate property.

Assault

Assault is …

  • intent to cause
  • the threat of immediate harm or offensive contact

England v. S&M Foods

How much is too much?

Other intentional torts?

Against persons

  • False imprisonment
  • IIED
  • Defamation (libel / slander / slander per se)
  • Privacy torts
  • Fraudulent misrepresentation (fraud, for short)
  • Abusive litigation

Other intentional torts?

Against property

  • Trespass to land
  • Trespass to chattels
  • Conversion

Negligence

Elements of negligence

  • A duty of care
  • That was breached
  • That caused
    • But for and proximate
  • Actual damage or loss

Palsgraf v. Long Island Railway Co.: proximate cause!

Hodges v. Nofsinger: comparative negligence

Taylor v. Baseball Club of Seattle: assumption of the risk

Leibeck v. McDonalds: reasonable damages? Comparative negligence?

Vosburg v. Putney: the eggshell rule

Strict Liability

  • Ultrahazardous activities, such as keeping wild animals
  • Product liability
    • We will cover in another chapter